Oliver Style: Airtightness and Moisture Control for Retrofits

0414gphhh Short video

Oliver Style of Praxis Resilient Buildings walks through the airtightness and moisture strategy for the retrofit of a 1954 multi-residential building in Barcelona, with solid brick walls about 29 centimeters thick insulated from the inside. Existing buildings there leak roughly 10 air changes per hour; EnerPHit requires one at 50 pascals. WUFI modeling showed a vapor check would cut the wall's drying, so the team chose a capillary-active, vapor-open wall with a water-repellent treatment outside.

Oliver Style holds many titles: director of Praxis Resilient Buildings, a Passive House consultant, and a component certifier. Oliver dove into moisture control and airtightness challenges in the EnerPHit of Monestir, a historic multifamily building in Barcelona, originally constructed with solid brick walls and an artificial stone façade. This project posed serious challenges ensuring airtightness and moisture control to meet Passive House standards, especially given that traditional Spanish buildings are often more than ten times as leaky as needed to meet Passive House requirements. In Oliver’s words meeting Passive House airtightness requirements is “key, a big challenge… but achievable”.

Get Early Access to Videos Like This Sign Up

The necessary approach became clear quickly. With the solid brick and artificial stone walls, adding insulation to the exterior would not be easy, so the building would need to be insulated internally. Of course, retrofitting from the interior posed its own problems, as standard vapor barrier and insulation methods run the risk of condensation and mold growth buildup because the brick exterior can act like a sponge when it rains. To combat this, the outside faces of the brick walls were treated with a brick cream, a water repellant. A capillary active vapor strategy was used along with the brick cream to control water absorption. For airtightness, the floors were coated with a liquid membrane, while the walls were sprayed with cellulose insulation. With Passive House-quality windows, the project was ultimately a strong success. The blower door test results on the first three floors were well below the stringent Passive House requirements, while the building’s energy consumption dropped by 37% because of the work, saving approximately €9,255 each year. Watch the video to learn about the details and catch up on the informative Q&A session.

View chat transcript.

Related articles

Related episode

This transcript was generated automatically and corrected with AI tools, but it has not been reviewed by a person. It contains errors, including misspelled names and misheard technical terms, and speakers are not identified. Don't quote from it without checking the recording.

Intro and news (00:00:04)

[00:00:04] Welcome everyone. This is the fourth global Passive House Happy Hour of our second year and episode number 56. Thank you for joining us. I'm Prudence Ferreira and I'm a proud member of the Passive House Accelerator. We couldn't do all of this without their support and without the support of the folks who sponsor them and all of you. I'm also a senior member of the carbon neutral design group at BR+A Consulting Engineers, and I lead their

[00:00:35] Passive House team and I maybe see a couple new faces. For those of you who are new, we're an inclusive gathering. We welcome everyone, no matter your reason for being here, whether you're an expert or a total newbie. You're in the right place to learn about Passive House and ghg reductions and building science and happy hump day, I was thinking. This week, I had an interview with one of our community members who's a student, a graduate student at University of

[00:01:05] Chicago. He was asking me all kinds of questions about the beginning of Passive House and how everything has evolved and he got me thinking how far we have come in a decade and Passive House Accelerator has got our policy summit coming up and I I'm talking to this fellow on the phone and I'm thinking about the policies that are coming into place now and the standards that are being created and the fact that we've got people now

[00:01:36] that are asking for Passive House, that don't really understand what it is, but they know they want it. I just think about where we were a decade ago when nobody knew anything about it and we were like banging on the doors just trying to get folks to understand, you know, the smallest little thing and trying to correct misperceptions. So I would like to open our show tonight with just a toast to how how far we've come and how fast this is ramping up. Guys, it's crazy ride, so please unmute yourselves

[00:02:07] yourselves and and join me in a toast. Here's, here's how far we've come. It's amazing. Cheers, all right. So we've got a great show. Our guest of honor and our teacher for the evening is Oliver Style, and he's got a master of science, masters of science and

[00:02:37] architecture and advanced environmental studies from the University of East London. He's also a Certified Passive House Consultant and has been for quite a while, as well as a component certifier, and he is director of Praxis Resilient Buildings, and they specialize in fabric first, performance optimization, thermal envelope design, PHPP, energy modeling and hygrothermal analysis, and also thermodynamic sims with EnergyPlus and 2d and 3d

[00:03:09] thermal bridge calculations so all the fun stuff, and also hvac system design specifications. So he is going to share with us tonight his journey in achieving Passive House airtightness requirements in the retrofit and how he achieved those without putting the building and its occupants at risk due to moisture damage. So we're going to hear about an EnerPHit retrofit of a historic building in Barcelona. Thank you for joining us, Oliver. We're

Presentation: Oliver Style (00:03:40)

[00:03:40] happy to have you. Thank you, Prudence. Thank you very much and it's a pleasure to be here with all of you. I've always seen these Passive House Accelerator events on announce on different social media and I think it's you've always got great topics and it's a pleasure to be here. So I'm gonna try and keep it fun and and factual and fast and and I hope we can have time for time for questions and an exchange which is

[00:04:13] always the most interesting part. So I understand a lot of you have experience in Passive House and and some not. I hope I could share a bit of my experience specifically on this project. So I'm just going to present a project we did a few years ago here in Barcelona in Spain, which was the Passive House retrofit of a multi-residential building which was a historic building. So we had certain

[00:04:44] limitations as to what we could do and we learned a lot along the way and I want to just present some of the kind of key key points of that. So, as many of you will know, the Passive House standard has the EnerPHit seal, which is the retrofit standard for Passive House. So it gives us two kind of routes to achieving certification. One is the demand method, which is kind of based on performance targets. So it's very similar to

[00:05:14] Passive House for new builds that's based on meeting limiting energy demands. It's a good route if you can insulate externally your building and it's more demanding, and if it also offers the component method, which is a prescriptive based on prescriptive targets, so the different building elements have to meet limiting u-values. So the component method is quite good for historic buildings or any buildings in which

[00:05:46] you can't put large amounts of insulation externally on the building. It's not quite as demanding as the demand method, but it's great to have these two kind of options. And then there's a common requirements for both certification routes, of which the key one is the airtightness. So we have to reach one air change per hour at a 50 pascal pressure difference. So that's the one that kind of causes

[00:06:17] terror in a lot of kind of design team. So it's a big challenge obviously in existing buildings to get to that, to that level of airtightness, but it's, it's clearly, it's achievable and I think, given the number of buildings that we have already built and in need of kind of a deep energy retrofitting, it's a real, really important to try and share these experiences and see where we can find low-cost, effective solutions for airtightness. So

[00:06:49] just to put you in a bit of context in Spain in terms of airtightness requirements. So as far as new build will need to reach 0.6 air changes per hour, like I mentioned, retrofit, EnerPHit, one. The Spanish building code for more compact building requires three air changes per hour and fifty less compact buildings six air changes per hour, and then existing buildings. This is going to vary a huge amount, but we'll we're talking roughly

[00:07:20] 10 air changes per hour of air infiltration majestic. So we need to get, you know, a 10 fold improvement, which is a quite a a challenge. So there's lots of reasons to improve the airtightness of building, as long as you control the ventilation. But I just want to show one of them which I think is interesting, relating to the stack effect. You know, when you warm air in a building, obviously due to its buoyancy it rises and that will cause air infiltration

[00:07:52] on the lower floors and exfiltration on the upper floors. One of the things that this can cause in non-Passive House buildings with lots of air filtration is the entrance of radon gas now, which is a carcinogenic gas found naturally in subsoil. This is a really interesting study by Barry McCarron et al., which looked at the concentration of radon gas in a series of completed certified Passive Houses in Ireland

[00:08:25] compared to non-Passive House buildings. And it was quite interesting because the concentration of radon gas in the Passive House houses both on the ground and the first floor, was below 40 becquerels per meter cubed and didn't really vary too much between the ground floor and the upper floor and the normal houses you know had quite a high concentration of radon gas on the lower floors. Basically because of that, you know, entrance of air coming in through on the ground floor. So

[00:08:56] sealing a building up is good in lots of ways, particularly in health terms related to radon gas. So the project I'm going to talk about is a multi-residential retrofit, a historic building built in 1954 in Barcelona. So this was basically a largely solid brick wall about 29 centimetres thick, with some artificial stone or some of

[00:09:27] the facades, so the some of the facades. So we couldn't insulate externally, we had to do everything internally. And solid brick walls, just as solid stone walls, quite complicated when you're insulating internally because if they are subject to driving rain from the outside, moisture can be coming in continually due to liquid transport and the brick, and if you insulate a lot on the inside it can be delicate in terms of

[00:09:59] moisture control, mold growth, condensation and so on. So, briefly, the airtightness strategy that we applied on the project was the whole building and per floor, so we had an airtight layer running around the external walls, also on the internal dividing walls which could connect us to the outside. At these points, and although we were going to test the building, the completed building

[00:10:30] just as one complete zone. We also did airtightness on a floor by floor level for two reasons: one was to reduce acoustic bridging and noise between different height, different flats, and the other was to facilitate preliminary airtightness testing on a floor by floor basis. So this is a great image, I think by Joseph little, which shows a little bit some of the complexity of insulating a solid wall. So because if we put insulation on the inside face of a

[00:11:01] solid wall, be it brick or stone, we're reducing the temperature on the face of that wall because we're insulating it against the indoor heat in the winter. So as we lower its temperature then its relative humidity rises and if we include a vapor barrier or a vapor check, we can also limit drying potential to the inside. So the standard rule of you know, put a vapor barrier in and put lots of insulation, has to be kind of looked at quite carefully in these walls because

[00:11:31] obviously, when it rains these walls, the material itself acts like a sponge and moisture starts coming in, and if we have a vapor barrier here, we can end up trapping that moisture in there. So one of the things we looked at in this project was: do we want a capillary active vapor open strategy or do we want a vapor barrier? Do we want to vapor check? Do we want dynamic vapor control? So we looked at various different solutions and came up with a one which was suited to the project in

[00:12:03] question and the local climate. So when looking at moisture control we can look at materials and they can have different functions. You know, a material can be airtight, it can be air permeable, it can be vapor permeable or it can be vapor impermeable, and it can be waterproof or not waterproof, and in any combination of those three you know. So we have a range of materials at our fingertips which we can use: be it plastic

[00:12:34] membranes, liquid membranes, gypsum plaster and so on, which offer, you know, different characteristics in that sense. So we did a whole lot of modelling for this project with the WUFI Dynamic hygrothermal Modeling Package. I'm just going to present basically three that we kind of distilled because we discovered that using vapor barriers or vapor checks could be counterproductive in

[00:13:04] in this case for this building in this climate. So this is a simulation run over ten years showing the relative humidity on the interface of the existing brick wall with insulation applied. Okay, so this is the relative humidity year after year, with peaks here of 90. Ideally we want to be below 80 percent to avoid creating an environment where mold growth can occur and, of course, we never want to reach condensation. So this is just internal gypsum plaster on this green

[00:13:36] line as an airtight layer, but no vapor control. This second blue line shows the same thing, but with the outer face of the brick treated with a water repellent treatment, which I'll talk about in a minute. So quite a good improvement. Then peaks of 80 of 80 relative humidity because of this water repellent treatment on the outer face of the brick. And then, just as a major comparison, what was going to hap? What would happen if we put a vapor check

[00:14:09] on the warm side of the insulation? What we found in the simulations was that, in fact, drying potential was reduced a bit and the peak relative humidity was was higher. So the solution that we opted for basically was this one. Sorry, wrong, this one okay. We went for a capillary active vapor open strategy coupled with a water repellent treatment on the outer face of the brick, which is sometimes called brick cream.

[00:14:42] I know historic building specialists and I'm sure some of you here tonight sometimes may question the effectiveness of a solution like this. But this is basically a treatment which you know is like a gore-tex: it reduces the by about 90 the water absorption of a brick, but it maintains its vapor permeability. So it's quite interesting for solid walls and historic buildings in which you can only insulate internally

[00:15:13] which are exposed to driving rain. Yeah, so it stops there. You know the amount of water getting in through liquid transport, but it means that the wall can still release water vapor. So of course, a lot of this analysis is really dependent on climate. This is just quickly a profile of the temperatures we have in Barcelona. It doesn't really get very cold when it gets to about north degrees here in Barcelona and everything just sort of stops and people start

[00:15:44] burning their furniture to stay warm and stuff, whereas in New York you, you know, you get down to -15 and everybody's still kind of happy. So this is quite different climates which need different solutions. So one of the main things we need to look at if we're using internal insulation on solid walls is the driving rain. So this is the climate file for Barcelona, which shows 500 mil 500 mil a year of rain.

[00:16:15] Whereas in the New York almost double that. So any wall, for example, which is going to be facing northeast or east in New York is going to be subject potentially to lots of driving rain. So those are the ones we need to be particularly careful at with and look at that in design phase. So just to summarize quickly what we found was the internal insulation of solid walls is tricky. You need to look at each one as a case by case basis. There's no one-size-fits-all.

[00:16:47] Clearly in cool, temperate climates, a lot of the climates that you have in North America. You know, internal vapor checks and or vapor barriers are often going to be needed, but it's important that they don't also reduce the drying potential to the inside of a solid wall, be it brick or stone. So important to look at each enclosure on a project by project basis. If possible, measure the water absorption of your existing wall.

[00:17:19] It's solid bricks or stone, and look at the robustness of your solution with the transient tools, if possible, WUFI, delphin and so on. The glazer method, you know, the simplified method for condensation analysis is probably far too simplified in the case of these kind of solid walls with internal insulation. So, and of course, it's always good to be able to monitor performance and learn and improve along the way.

[00:17:49] So the airtightness strategy we applied in this project was, just as I said, very simple: gypsum plaster applied on the interface of the existing brick wall, the ground floor. We had a liquid membrane sprayed onto the terrazzo floors and the join was with airtight paint on intermediate floors. We also applied the liquid membrane on the floors and the gypsum plaster on the

[00:18:20] walls. Insulation was sprayed cellulose between galvanized steel profiles and plasterboard. The profiles were brought in from the walls slightly to avoid thermal bridging and make sure the insulation could get in there. And then we had the foam glass insulation on the floors. So there was already some existing plaster on the interface of the brick walls. That was all cleaned off and then replastered, so it was

[00:18:52] a solution that you know the local trades people knew well and it was applied at reasonable cost. And we also did all of the internal walls as well to avoid any leaks going through to the outside walls. This is some images of the liquid membrane on the ground floor and intermediate floors. Given the results that we got on the blower door test, we could have probably done without the liquid membrane on the intermediate floors.

[00:19:22] You know, and some cost savings would have been possible there. But this is a solution we apply, which then was just sprayed on there, on the joint with the, with the, with the walls, to seal them. Service penetrations, of course, also sealed with plaster and airtight paint. This is a kind of picture of how not to do. Service penetrations have lots of

[00:19:52] pipes. You know, ideally you want to separate them, get enough space to get in there with tapes or with airtight paint. Unfortunately here we couldn't, because there was literally no other way we could get all of these pipes in. So they actually behind the render. You can see there all of the pipes came through a pre-cut polystyrene XPS board which was previously sealed. So anyway, we had to keep on top of all of the service penetrations cables for the motors of the blinds as well.

[00:20:24] And there you go. So this is just a few images of the insulation system which is sprayed cellulose internally, which is interesting solution because you get a homogeneous, complete covering layer of insulation. Important to do it in the summertime or the warmer months because obviously there's quite a lot of liquid in the cellulose once it's applied and if you then seal everything up in the winter when it's all wet, you could have a few moisture problems. So recommendable to do this in the warmer months if possible.

[00:20:55] The windows, we had them factory, we had the blind casings fixed to the window frames in the factory and they were delivered on site like this, so that the window frames and the blind casings were all were all delivered on site together, which is a real, which is a great solution because it just saves lots of headaches in terms of airtightness through these blind casings, which is essential in warm climates, you know, to have some shading and

[00:21:27] the windows were fixed with the metal steel brackets to the interface of the wall airtight tapes and of course they were. The windows were basically installed in the insulation layer to the inside, so reducing the thermal bridge installation cartridge. So here you can see a kind of wood fibre and polyurethane a board to hold it set the window on. These steel brackets obviously point thermal bridges, but

[00:21:57] but a good solution. And the airtight tape here tapes of the gypsum plaster. So the airtight tape was put on before the brackets and then fixed to the wall and taped. Important to get some: get some primer on the walls before you tape so that everything sticks nice and well. So we did the airtightness testing on all of the three floors of the upper three floors of the building. Here you can see some of the smoke coming in from the hand-held smoke generator. So there was a bit of

[00:22:28] leakage through the window seals here, you know, but really it wasn't significant because the results were very good. But one of the great things about this famous blower door test is that you can really see what's happening and and in the preliminary test with the smoke, you can correct things if need be. And I think it's a great way for everybody trades, project design people to sort of understand what the scope of the

[00:23:01] the challenges and and what works and what doesn't. So here's a few images of the blower door machine, which many of you will probably have already seen. You know it's a machine that pressurizes or depressurizes the building. It means you can imagine the amount of air coming in and coming out. We had a couple of guys hanging out the windows with the smoke generators and the results were really good. On the first floor we got 0.36 changes per hour, 50 Pascal. So

[00:23:31] quite far below the requirement for Passive House new building build: 0.31 on the second floor, 0.47 on the third floor. A few more leaks to the roof, so really good results. Sort of well below the limit for Passive House retrofit. And just finally a quick look at what the impact of air infiltration is on the energy consumption of this building. So these are modeled energy consumption for heating, cooling, hot water, electricity of the existing building

[00:24:02] with 10 air changes per hour and then the energy demands if we reduce airtightness to 0.6, so 37 at savings just because of airtightness in the Barcelona climate. So clearly if you're in northern Canada those savings are going to be far greater. You know, in Barcelona we don't have very harsh winters and euros, but electricity cost of 19 cents per

[00:24:34] kilowatt hour. The savings for this building is in the region of 9 000 euros a year for the whole building. So even in the Barcelona climate, reducing airtightness to Passive House levels. This has an economic rationale and of course, other many more important ones to do with health comfort, reduction in pathologies and moisture problems and so on. So that's pretty much it. Thanks a lot for your time. Here's my contact

Q&A (00:25:04)

[00:25:04] details and I hope we can have some questions in discussion. Fantastic, thank you so much, Oliver, and we know that it's really late for you, so stick around as long as you would like to and you'll be thankful for any of your time. Great, I would happily stay around for a bit. I'll need to get some sleep at some point, but okay, well, let's dive into the

[00:25:34] questions, Oliver, I guess. First one is: how many cups of coffee have you had in the last hour or so? I think there's number two. All right, that's pretty good. First one: we're gonna head over to Cameron, Duncan, Karen, Oliver, thank you for the presentations very good. I have sort of a side question because in my area we have historic buildings that people keep adding on to. So my question was: with Passive House, do you, do you have a hybrid is, do you

[00:26:06] have a, have a. If you're building a new addition and you have a existing historic property, do you do EnerPHit on the existing and a separate standard Passive House Institute (PHI) for the for the new work? I mean, I think it's possible probably to do a variety of different things. I mean, if you have the certification

[00:26:39] criteria. The Passive House Institute (PHI) certification criteria is that if you have an existing building which has part retrofit, then I think you probably can do the whole thing according to EnerPHit retrofit. I think it just depends a little bit on each any specific project, but I think the you know one of the most important things is that you know there may be it's possible to have an exemption based on the kind of

[00:27:10] building and the limitations that it has. Obviously historic buildings you're not going to be able to do certain things that you could. On you on a new build will kind of dictate the kind of the route that you can go. So I don't know if that answers your question very well, but I mean I think the basic underlying rule, the underlying concept I think for retrofit is that you know it has to be the whole building. So

[00:27:41] you can't retrofit one part of an existing building and get a certification, at least from the, from the PH, PHI, PH, PHI. What you can do, though, I think, is get a. You know, you could do a step-by-step retrofit. You can have a pre-certification of one part of a building. So, yeah, I mean, I think the bottom line is: you know, you, you need to really do a whole building, and if that's not possible, then you can do a, do a

[00:28:11] step by step. Okay, well, hopefully I'll find out. Okay, thanks, Cameron. One in the world, thanks, excellent. All right, Jeff, you have a whole bunch of questions. Why don't you pick one and we'll come back to you afterwards? Oh my gosh, I have to pick. Yes, well, I guess I'll combine

[00:28:42] two of them into one, which is the. It's curious about the age of the building and how many renovations it has undergone over its lifetime, and if that on either simplified or complicated things, that's a good question. I mean, I think, from what I remember, what I understand, the building was renovated once it was originally built, then it was turned into school and then, when we got to the

[00:29:14] project. That was kind of the second renovation, so you know it wasn't. It's not especially old building, it was 1919, built in 1954, but I think it had been retrofitted once previous to this one. Yes, did that complicate things, you think, or was it did it help, or I I mean, I think, I mean, was it wasn't really? You know it

[00:29:46] wasn't really an issue one way or the other, because you know everything was stripped internally. There was a lot of structural work we've done. We've done reinforcement of structure and so on. So you know what had been done previously wasn't didn't sort of change things too much in terms of what was what was done. I mean, I think the question is always: would like to fit you know, how much can you leave there and make the most of to reduce costs?

[00:30:18] You know, and the environmental impact of the project. But you know, with retrofit you start scratching away and then you find all kinds of things which you didn't think were there. You've got to be careful and obviously make sure that the end result is going to be a lasting solution. I mean, I think one of the things that I learned from all of this Passive House retrofit is that it's anafit provides a really good road map for retrofitting buildings, because

[00:30:49] there's, there's a lot of. There's possibility to do a lot of things in the wrong combinations and leading to really bad results. You know, for example, if you change windows in a building, existing building, you, without doing anything to the ventilation system, you know you can rapidly get a call from your client saying: all of you know I've got condensation everywhere because obviously you change the windows, you reduce the air leaks and if you haven't compensated that with a ventilation system, then you can generate problems. So the benefit, you know,

[00:31:22] approach is good because it's systematic and it's holistic. You know you have to take everything into account and it's a good way of making sure that retrofits are safe and free from moisture damage. And, of course, one of the great things about Passive House community like here is, you know, there's lots of sharing of information, lots of people who can get together, have happy hours and geek out and lots of different technical solutions and share that information, which I think is great.

[00:31:54] Thank you very much. It was great and it was wonderful having you in the breakout group, right, thank you all. Right, Jeff, I'll put you back at the end of the line. And that was pretty crafty what you did with those two questions, I will allow it's a nice work. Over to Joe. Okay, I think sort of a really interesting presentation. I don't know if you saw everybody kind of lean in when you started mentioning brick cream and it's like a bunch of questions about that. So would you be able to just speak a little bit more to the decision to use that, and maybe you

[00:32:25] know how it measured up economically versus just the reality of what you have the space for on the project. Sure that's a yeah great question, John. I mean, we looked at this I this solution. I don't know the detailed technical, chemical, physical properties of the product, other than what I what I basically described in art's history, because it will basically maintain vapor permeability but it will reduce

[00:32:55] water coming in through the brick. There's those issues, of course you. It has a useful working life, so it depends on which manufacturer, which product and who you talk to. But that may be 15, 20 years, so you know, in theory you would need to reapply it 20 years further ahead for it to be effective. Having said that, if you apply

[00:33:25] when you retrofit, then at least you're going to protect your building in the first few years, where there's more moisture in the building anyway, because you've just built it, you know, and all of the wet materials plus the gypsum, more the concrete is still drying, so it's going to give you protection in the most sort of critical period. It didn't change the physical appearance of the bricks much at all, because it's always transparent. Obviously, if you apply it to one brick and then next to it, you don't apply anything, you will notice a slight

[00:33:55] difference, but it doesn't change the aesthetics of the of the brick at all. The cost, I can't actually remember, but I think it was a region of 30 euros a square meter, if I, if I remember rightly. So it was. It was an expense, but it was. You know, given the analysis and the simulation results, we advise our founder of solutions. So I mean, I think it's, it's a really

[00:34:26] interesting product for these kinds of walls that are that you can't render on, you can't put a rain screen, you can't protect it from the driving rain. I don't know if it's if it's common in the US, but it's something that's being used here increasingly in retrofit. It's quite interesting because you know you you've got this problem that these materials are sponges. You know they take up water and that water wants to go in and then

[00:34:57] you have also moisture from the inner inside of the building trying to go out and you know, so that can help. Yeah, great, thank you welcome. Yeah, Oliver, that was a was a a pretty lively part of your discussion. There might be a few more questions and and you might have answered a few more, so we'll see how this goes over to. Just sorry, Jess Brooks. Hey, I love your presentation. I'm just getting into Passive House and I'm particularly

[00:35:27] interested in preservation. So I'm curious when you mentioned that preservation, preservationists may not be interested in this as a technique and I'm curious as to why there might be some hesitancy. Is it just the fact that there's a cost associated with it down the road in 20 years, or if it's like degrading? That's not? Yeah, you know what I'm saying. Yeah, thanks, Jess. I mean it's just. I mean you know it's kind of here. So I haven't actually had an active discussion directly with too many historic

[00:35:59] building experts. But I have just read a few reservations, I think basically on the basis of the fact, not not economic, you know reasons, but just that some questions about whether it affects the vapor permeability of a brick, which for historic building reasons obviously is important to maintain. Because if you, if you put a vapor, if you reduce the vapor permeability of the outer face of a brick, you can be creating more moisture problems. So

[00:36:30] But so I think that's that's what I understand to be the only sort of issue there, and and but also my understanding is that these products will only reduce the or they will only increase the water vapor resistance factor by about 10, but they will reduce the water absorption by about 90, you know. So it's like having your boots, you know your hiking boots, which when you get it from the shop it's great. The water doesn't come in, and then after about a year you know you start getting water coming in and then you can

[00:37:00] buy the spray, the gore-tex spray, which is a silicone-based thing, the same as this and you spray on your boots and then the water doesn't come in again. So it's that kind of concept. But you know, I think my my conclusion that it's safely used on historic buildings, but I think it's always good to contrast that with experts, of which I'm not an expert on specific historic pillars. Thank you so much. Okay, excellent, and now we're heading over to

[00:37:34] Devon. Hi Oliver, thank you so much. I was amazing presentation, awesome work. I'm. I was curious, you know, regarding the porosity of the building initially. Was that measured in some way or in how? How do you do? That was my question. Great, yeah, great question, Devin, no, we didn't measure the porosity of the bricks. We would like to have done that, but the for various

[00:38:05] mainly economic reasons, the client didn't want to go ahead with it. What we just what we did was we modeled different bricks that have been classified in there in the WUFI database and other databases. So obviously, bricks, every bricks a world in itself, especially historic bricks. You know they can be very different in terms of their water absorption, their thermal conductivity, their heat capacity, their density. And if you were to measure it, what would you use? What type of measurement would you like to use? Like casting tubes, yeah, casted tubes? I mean, I haven't actually

[00:38:36] ever done that measurement myself. But I understand tubes inserted into the wall at different points to measure the water absorption, right like a rhylum tube kind of. With a little like a rhylum tube I've been. I was under the impression that I mean at least the, just the, if I may, the and I don't know what validity this has but the I think it's the American Concrete Institute or Association they may, they kind of didn't so much think that was, that was such a. The rylam tube was so good because so

[00:39:07] many points would be needed over the face of it because it varies so greatly. But I really appreciate it and I'm curious about the. What product did you use? That siloxane based product? What was that? We used Mapei Antipluviol manufacturer, and is there a space between the outer? Why of the brick? And is there an interstitial space of any sort? Or is it all solid masonry, full solid masonry? Yes, yeah, cool, nicer, amazing work.

[00:39:39] Thank you very much, so much, thank you, yeah, no, really good point about the measurement. It's like when you start to monitor a building, it's like you know where do you monitor, where are the sensors, what temperature is it picking up and so on. So you need to. You know it's clearly an issue about that. But I mean, my conclusion would be: it's great to measure something and then have some data and then contrast it with your models and just remember that all models are wrong. I'm going to ask you one real quick one: if you had to do over again, would you do anything differently? If we had to do what? Sorry, if you did

[00:40:10] have to do over again, would you, might you'd consider doing anything differently? Good question, I don't. I don't think so, except that we I would probably not have put the liquid membrane on the intermediate floors to save a bit of money, because you know that's 20 euros a square meter and we didn't really need that in the end. Otherwise, I think we would have pretty much done it the same. Yeah, awesome. Thank you again, and over to you, Mark. Thank you, Oliver on the on the interior, after we get

[00:40:43] past the brick. There's some photos showing the stud bay is filled with the cellulose and it didn't catch behind the studs. Was there an insulating barrier there as well? Yes, well, we just moved. We just brought the studs in slightly from the end, from the outer wall, so that the sprayed cellulose insulation could get in there behind the stud. Yeah, so the insulation

[00:41:13] got behind the stud and just, you know it wasn't a huge thickness, in most cases two or three centimeters, but just to make sure that we had at least a continuity of insulation there and not a break with a with a steel stud, which obviously is a thermal problem. So that was it. Yeah, we just we just brought the studs in and got a bit of insulation in behind. We didn't have a big thickness, you know, it was five to seven centimeters, which is not a lot in Passive House terms at all.

[00:41:44] That's what I was going to ask, roughly, what does the break be between the masonry and the stud? Then at that point for the site it varied a bit because none of the walls are straight, you know. But you know two or three centimeters, yeah, two, three centimeters. So I mean, the good thing about the component method with retrofit and Passive House is that at least in the Barcelona climate I don't know what, it is probably more in your kind of climates but you can put five centimeters of insulation and you can comply with that. With the requirements it might be seven

[00:42:15] or eight centimeters where you are, but it's not a huge amount. And that's specifically for a reason because the you know the Passive House Institute, we've been looking at this problem and throwing a lot of insulation on an internal wall, on the interface of a solid wall, can be a problem. So it's it's, it's good, but yeah, it wasn't a huge amount, it was, it was fine. I have four more questions, but I will stop there and I appreciate the response. Thank you, yeah, you will mark. You'll start breaking down, mister Zack. Who are you buddy? All right, thanks,

Sponsors (00:42:47)

[00:42:47] Oliver. This has been fantastic, really inspiring work. Thank you, I'm gonna I have a couple of announcements about what's coming up next week. Before I do that, I want to thank our sponsors for making this, all of this, happen. So thank you to our founding sponsors. 475 High Performance Building Supply, Baxt Ingui Architects, Glavel foam glass gravel, Minotair, all-in-one HVAC and Mitsubishi Electric Trane HVAC US, Partel, RDH Building Science,

[00:43:19] Sto Corp and Zola Windows. This our stakeholder partner is NYSERDA and our patron sponsors are aero barrier, BR+A Consulting Engineers, Brennan Insulation and airtightness, Innotech Windows + Doors and u.s engineered wood t-stud. So thank you to all of our sponsors and a big shout out again to Sto Corp. Sto Corp for being our sponsor of the week.

Published: April 14, 2021
Contributor: Oliver Style